A deck is more than just an outdoor platform — it’s where family cookouts, morning coffees, and summer sunsets happen. But over time, even the best-built decks show signs of wear. If your deck is looking aged or has damage, you might be wondering: Should I resurface it or rebuild it entirely?
At Eled Decking, we help Long Island homeowners make the right call based on safety, cost, and long-term performance. Let’s break down the pros and cons of each option.
📞 (631) 552-6884 | Get Your Free Estimate
Understanding the Difference
Deck Resurfacing involves replacing only the top decking boards and possibly railings while keeping the underlying frame.
Deck Rebuilding means tearing down the existing structure and starting fresh with new framing, boards, and hardware.
When Deck Resurfacing Makes Sense
Resurfacing is a great option when your deck’s frame is structurally sound but the surface has cosmetic or minor wear.
Signs You Can Resurface:
-
Solid, rot-free frame and joists
-
Minor surface cracks or splinters
-
Stains or fading from sun exposure
-
Railing replacement or upgrades needed
Advantages of Resurfacing:
-
Cost-effective: Less expensive than a full rebuild
-
Faster: Usually completed in a few days
-
Customizable: Choose new materials like composite decking for low maintenance
Limitations:
-
Can’t fix underlying structural problems
-
Frame lifespan will still determine total deck longevity
When Rebuilding Is the Best Option
If your deck’s structure is failing, resurfacing won’t address the safety risks. A rebuild ensures a fresh, secure foundation.
Signs You Need a Full Rebuild:
-
Rotten or sagging support beams
-
Loose or corroded hardware
-
Deck sways or feels unstable
-
Frame doesn’t meet current building codes
-
Extensive water or insect damage
Advantages of Rebuilding:
-
Safety First: Completely new structure meets modern standards
-
Customization: Change the layout, size, or style of your deck
-
Longer Lifespan: Starts the clock over for decades of use
Considerations:
-
Higher cost than resurfacing
-
Takes longer to complete
Choosing the Right Decking Materials
Whether resurfacing or rebuilding, your choice of materials matters.
-
Pressure-Treated Wood: Affordable and widely used, but requires regular maintenance.
-
Cedar or Redwood: Naturally resistant to decay, beautiful appearance, higher cost.
-
Composite Decking: Durable, low maintenance, and resistant to moisture — perfect for Long Island’s climate.
The Eled Decking Approach
We don’t believe in one-size-fits-all answers. Our process includes:
-
Thorough Inspection: Checking every beam, joist, and post for safety.
-
Clear Recommendations: Honest advice on whether resurfacing or rebuilding is more cost-effective long term.
-
Expert Installation: Skilled craftsmanship for a beautiful, lasting result.
Make the Right Choice for Your Home
Your deck should be a safe, inviting space for years to come. Whether you’re giving it a facelift or starting from scratch, Eled Decking is here to help you choose the best path forward.
📞 Call (631) 552-6884 or request your free estimate online today.
